In the field of precision machining, the performance of Tungsten carbide saw blade milling cutter coating depends largely on their surface coating technology. Physical vapor deposition (PVD) and chemical vapor deposition (CVD) are the two mainstream coating processes at present, but their application scenarios and effects are significantly different. This article will analyze how to choose the best coating solution for tungsten carbide milling cutters from three aspects: technical characteristics, application scenarios and selection recommendations.
1. Technical comparison between PVD and CVD
1.1. Process principles and characteristics PVD (physical vapor deposition):
Through the evaporation and ionization of metal targets in a vacuum environment, a thin coating (3~5μm) is formed on the surface of the tool. The deposition temperature is low (about 500℃), which avoids the decrease in the strength of the substrate material, and the coating is under compressive stress, with strong resistance to crack propagation, suitable for complex cutting edges and sharp tools. Typical coating materials: TiN, TiCN, TiAlN, AlCrN, etc., suitable for high-speed steel and cemented carbide tools. CVD (chemical vapor deposition): The coating is generated through chemical reaction at high temperature (800~1000℃), and the thickness can reach 10~20μm. The coating has high bonding strength and can deposit high-stability materials such as α-phase alumina (Al₂O₃), but high temperature can easily lead to a decrease in substrate strength, and the coating is under tensile stress, which is easy to produce microcracks6810. Typical coating materials: TiC, TiCN, Al₂O₃, mostly used for carbide indexable inserts.
1.2. Performance differences
| Indicators |
PVD |
CVD |
| Coating thickness |
3~5μm (thin, keep the edge sharp) |
10~20μm (thicker, more wear-resistant) |
| Processing temperature |
temperature below 500℃ (no loss of matrix strength) |
800~1000℃ (matrix may soften) |
| Stress state |
Compressive stress (suppresses cracks) |
Tensile stress (prone to microcracks) |
| Applicable scenarios |
Intermittent cutting (such as milling, drilling) |
Continuous cutting (such as turning, roughing) |
| Environmental protection |
No chemical waste liquid, environmentally friendly |
Waste gas and waste liquid need to be treated |
|
|
|
|
|
|
2.1. Situations where PVD is preferred
Intermittent cutting: such as milling and drilling, the tool is subjected to impact loads, and the compressive stress characteristics of PVD can effectively prevent the coating from peeling off. High-precision edge requirements: PVD coating is thin and has little effect on the edge geometry, suitable for precision milling cutters, taps, etc. Processing non-ferrous metals: such as aluminum alloys and titanium alloys, PVD’s TiAlN coating can reduce built-up edge and improve surface quality.
2.2. Situations where CVD is preferred
High-temperature continuous cutting: such as rough turning of steel parts, CVD’s Al₂O₃ coating is resistant to high-temperature oxidation and extends tool life. High wear resistance requirements: Thick coating is suitable for heavy cutting of high-strength materials (such as cast iron and stainless steel). Economic considerations: CVD has a low industrialization cost and is suitable for mass production of standard blades.
3. Practical Tips for Optimizing Coating Selection
3.1. Combining processing materials and working conditions
When processing non-ferrous materials such as graphite and high-silicon aluminum alloys, diamond coating (CVD process) is an ideal choice, but it should be avoided for steel parts. In the processing of stainless steel or high-strength steel, multi-layer composite coatings (such as TiCN+Al₂O₃) can take into account both wear resistance and anti-adhesion.
3.2. Pay attention to coating technology trends
PVD technology progress: For example, sputtering technology has achieved 12μm thick coatings, expanding its application in rough processing. Hybrid coating process: PVD and CVD are used in combination (such as CVD base layer + PVD functional layer), which can combine the advantages of both.
3.3. Actual test verification
Evaluate the actual performance of the coating through test cutting, such as cutting force, tool life and workpiece surface roughness, especially in the processing of new materials (such as composite materials).
4. Conclusion
PVD and CVD each have their own advantages in tungsten steel saw blade milling cutter coating. The selection needs to comprehensively consider processing conditions, material properties and cost-effectiveness. With the innovation of coating technology, more attention will be paid to the integration of multi-layer composite coating and environmental protection technology in the future to provide better solutions for efficient and precise processing.
If you want to purchase tungsten carbide saw blades, please contact us
